If You’re Opposed To Hunting On Sundays, Be Honest About Your Reasons
June 27, 2006
There are few states left that have a total ban on Sunday hunting. Most states allow it completely, some restrict it to small game only and some like North Carolina prohibit the activity in its entirety and have for 137 years.
We all have opinions, hunters and non-hunters, about Sunday hunting. Let’s be honest about the reasons we have our opinions and stop spewing scare tactics and misinformation simply because we don’t agree.
I hunt in Maine. I am opposed to a Sunday hunting season on deer because I don’t believe that it will gain most people any added hunting time. Why? Maine is on of few states that doesn’t have a deer overpopulation problem in the vast majority of its wildlife management districts. Therefore, the Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife decides how many deer need to be harvested and set season dates accordingly.
It was not that many years ago when Maine was reduced to a deer hunting season that lasted barely two weeks. It has now grown back to about 4 without any Sunday hunts and we’ve been able to lengthen that with a special muzzle loader season. In short, if Maine added Sunday hunting, it could very well produce a shorter hunting season – not necessarily fewer days.
Those who favor a Sunday hunt in Maine say they work all week and hunting Sundays would give them a chance to hunt more. I won’t argue with that reasoning. More hunters in the woods on Sundays would more than likely mean more deer killed. If too many deer are killed this way, officials would have only one recourse – to shorten the season.
In states where it is difficult for game experts to get enough deer harvested to have an effective impact on blossoming deer populations, a Sunday hunt might be an effective tool. In my opinion, a consideration of a Sunday hunt should be one of science and not emotion prompted by misinformation.
Let’s look for a minute at some of the arguments those opposed to a Sunday hunt like to use. The first is one that I frankly am tired of hearing. “Can’t we have one day out of the week where we will be safe being outside”? They then go on about all the accidents that have happened from hunting mishaps. I won’t deny there have been and will continue to be accidents from hunting. We are all human and prone to mistakes but if you compare the safety record of hunting against hundreds of other activities, hunting is safe, very safe.
Another poor excuse is the one where opponents lament about not being able to go outside and take a walk. Blaze orange or hunter orange as it is often called, has been an extremely effective safety device for hunters that has reduced hunting accidents drastically. Combine that with good hunter education and we have produced a sport that is one of the safest in the world, including golf. Blaze orange hats, vests, jackets and more come in sizes that fit everyone, including non-hunters. Hunters put the clothing on and walk for hours in the woods, safely. What makes them any different than someone interested in taking a stroll down a country lane? By the way, they make better fashion items in blaze orange for animals than they do humans, so you can adorn your little guy to go with you.
The last thing I want to point out is the one about economics that seems to be rearing its head in many discussions these days in attempts to thwart hunting by anti-hunting groups. I saw this statement in the News and Observer.com this morning. It was made by the state representative in North Carolina to the Humane Society of the United States, Bob Reder.
While hunters spend an estimated $438 million annually on their activity in North Carolina, wildlife watchers outspend them by nearly two to one and generate $827 million for the state’s economy. Forcing these people to stay home on Sundays is not only unfair but also fiscally irresponsible.
I don’t want to argue whether or not Mr. Reder facts are true or not. What I do want to point out is that for centuries, hunters, fisherman and trappers have funded state’s fish and wildlife agencies to provide the general public a healthy wildlife population to view. Now they want to lay claim to that achievement by saying they spend more money than hunters do.
Whether there is hunting on Sundays or not will not have a negative effect on any state’s economy. People will adjust and Sunday hunting will go on for the most part unnoticed. Hunting is an extremely safe activity and people need to know that taking a drive in their car to go moose watch or see elk, birds, fish or have a picnic lunch, is more dangerous than going into the woods properly clothed during hunting season.
Be honest and truthful about why you are for or against Sunday hunting. If you are just opposed to hunting, say so. If you don’t want hunters on your property, say so. If you want to hunt Sundays because it’s the only day of the week you have to hunt, say so. If you think Sundays is God’s day and it shouldn’t be spent hunting, say so, but don’t spread misinformation, also known as lies.
Tom Remington
Most Commented Posts
If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!
We feature the latest news, events and politics effecting the sports of hunting, fishing, and all outdoor activities in North America.
I know you are talking about NC but the same argument is going on in Maine.
One point I would like to make is Maine law only requires HUNTERS WITH FIREARMS to where orange in the woods, not landowners and the average ‘Joe’.
So that question quickly turns into; would YOU take that woodsy stroll dressed in whatever you happened to have on that day?
Again, my biggest argument is this;
If 10% of Mainers are PRO-hunt and 10% of Mainers are ANTI-hunt, then 80% don’t care one way or the other. Do we really need to change something that may sway even one persons opinion? Do we really want to tip the scales?
It is a natural thing for people to fear what they do not understand. Some folks want to ride wheelers around the their woodlot, or ride their horses on the trails that hunters use. This interaction may not be a good thing, Tom.
I know all about the “target identifacation law” but I also understand the mentality of SOME Mainers when it comes to deer hunting!
I remember a quieter time when Maine used to close its stores on Sunday. Sometimes I wish it was still that way!
[...] I think that most of the support for Hunting and gun ownership is people on the “Right†and the animal wackos are made up of more people on the “Left†The people on the “Right†see more issues as black or white and the “Left†sees everything as gray. I’m unwilling to support someone doing something that I see as “wrong†or “cheating†and I think there are many others in our camp that think the same way and that is where our struggle is. Earlier this week the NC State Director for the Humane Society wrote an editorial opposed to the Sunday Hunting Study being conducted here in NC ( Earlier post about this in the Black Bear Blog) He basically said that 6 days a week is enough time for hunting, is he supportive of hunting? heck no!! He knows that if he takes the approach that 6 days is enough and the Sunday Hunting Prohibition remains that he has won. If the true views of his organization and the supports were put forth that they would support a total ban on hunting, that private ownership of pets be done away with, that all medical testing on animals be halted, and if necessary that terrorist acts be carried out to fulfill these goals the paper might not(it was the N&O so who knows for sure) of even printed his editorial. [...]
[...] Last week in the Black Bear Blog as well as here in Moose Droppings there was postings about an editorial in the N&O from Bob Reder of the Humane Society about his opposition to the study to allow Sunday Hunting. Today’s N&O published some response letters from hunters to Mr Reder’s editorial. Mr. Reder asserted that if the Sunday Hunting ban was lifted that many families would be held hostage in their homes because it would be unsafe to go outside. Kirk Port of Raleigh in his response correctly points out some of the major flaws in Mr. Reder’s argument. Mr. Reder cited cases from outside of NC, the fatality in Maine was 20 years ago, and I know Maine did not and still does not allow Sunday Hunting. (The other Letter) [...]
I have been hunting in NC for about 18 years now. And each year, I see more and more deer. In order to control the deer population, I think we need to do one of the two:
Allow hunting on Sunday or extend the season at least another 30 days.
I am for hunting on Sunday’s.
Thank you for your comment John. Often in these debates science is left out and the consequences of allowing a deer herd to become too large.
If you want an example of overpopulated deer country, look at what is going on in Wisconsin.